![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
It seems incomprehensible to some media commentators that over 181 people could die in fires in Australia. They have been casting about, trying to place blame, saying that things were done poorly, done wrong.
This is not true. What is true is that the right things to do, the things that kept you alive in every other year, every other fire, are now no longer necessarily right.
Everyone who lives through an Australian summer has some experience of bushfire, even if it is only red-blazing sunsets in smoke-filled skies. The trees explode on the hot summer days, and half the flora is designed to regenerate after burning.
There are rules. You choose whether you will leave early or stay and fight. If you're leaving, you pack your papers and photos, grab the kids and pets, make sure you have water and towels or blankets in the car in case the worst happens, and you leave before or when you see the smoke. Lock the house and tell the fire brigade where it is. They'll do what they can.
Stick to the main roads, drive steadily, obey the police or the fierys, pick up pedestrians if you need to. When you get to the evacuation centre, give your names and details, call your friends. Let the officials know if you move on.
If you stay, you fill everything you can inside the house with water. You wet everything you can outside. Clear all debris from around the house (you should have done this weeks ago). Use a tractor if you have one. Fuck the garden, you can replant. Bring in the pets. Have the car nearby, have the keys in your pocket. Have your backpacks of things each of you really need ready to go. Do what you can for the horses. If the flames are small and slow, you can stay outside and keep hosing. If they're fast and large, go in. Close everything. Put wet towels around every gap, have a ladder near the roof access. Stay down, keep the kids together; the bathroom is a good place, it's cool and strong and you can sit them in the bath. If you see flames coming inside and can wet them, do so. Wait till the front passes.
This is what you do in a normal fire. This is what you have time to do in a normal fire.
When it passes, you run around the house and put out the flames that are starting inside. You climb into the roof cavity and wet down any hot spots. You go outside and use your generator to pump water from the tanks, or the pool or the dam to hose down the roof and the property. If the house is too well alight, you leave it. You grab the kids, pets and packs and you climb into the car and drive away. The car is usually all right; it's the embers blown by the wind that have set fire to the house. You can often drive out through the burnt region, there's nothing left for the fire there anymore. Your tires may be a bit fucked-up by the hot tarmac, but it doesn't matter, you'll get to the country fire authority, or the town, or the sports oval.
This is what happens normally.
You stand around with the CFA and the SES and the Parks service and every other firefighter, and you shake hands and you say thanks, or bad luck, and you pitch in if your house is standing and your neighbour's isn't, and you see about handing out sausage sandwiches and cups of bad coffee and good tea. The CWA ladies bring cakes and fruit and toys for the little ones and make sure the fierys all have a good feed and get some sleep. The McDonald's managers and the local takeaway owners bring trays of juice and water and burgers and sandwiches, the pub brings beer by the slab.
Every year, it happens. Houses burn, livestock are lost, and people turn to each other and say that it sounded like a train, that the fire moved as fast as they could run. That they lost the house but the kids are okay. It's horrible, but it's normal.
None of this is normal.
This fire moved faster than any car, twice as fast in some places. The noise was like a jet engine, they say, and the oxygen was sucked from the air leaving people sheltering inside gasping desperately as the front passed. The weather had stood above 40 for a week, the air was crisp and the vegetation bone dry. On the day the fires swept through it was 46 in Victoria.
It's never 46. Never. Not till now. The records were shattered by several degrees.
The radiant heat has been described as like Dresden. Houses were exploding into flame ahead of the firefront. While normal ember attacks give you a decent length of time for the house to stand before it is unsalvageable (the eaves and under the house start smouldering, small fires begin, but it's usually after the front has past that the house really catches light), this time large properties were gone in minutes. Normally the embers strike when the fire is up to a kilometre away, this time it was many times that.
Some people trying to escape died of dehydration before the fire reached them. Others who escaped the flames had skin crisped from their bodies as they ran well ahead or away. Some lived, and are in hospital fighting for their lives now. Cars have turned into makeshift crematoria, sometimes beside trees that are scorched from heat but not burned.
There were warnings where there could be warnings. All day the ABC and the local stations kept as far ahead of the fire as they could, but for Kinglake and some other towns, the fire moved faster than the news. The brigades were mostly fighting established fronts, trying to keep them from residential areas. The new fronts took them by surprise, many coming from nothing, possibly from arsonists.
I know that it is human to look for blame. I know that there are many who are angry and who wish to say that something or someone failed. But for the most part, no one failed. It was impossible to succeed.
There are systems. This country is used to fire and plans accordingly. The fire danger is rated from 1 to 100, so the authorities know how prepared they need to be, how many crews they need in place. On Saturday in Victoria, it was 320. More than three times worse than the experienced authorities had imagined they would ever need to prepare for. There was no way that people could deal with those flames.
And still they went out and did what they could. When I worked for the parks service in NSW I helped in two safe areas of two comparatively piddling fires. I was scared to the bones, and I am someone who keeps her head in a crisis. The sheer mental toughness of everyone who went up against those fires cannot be overstated.
So if your news service starts with the question 'what went wrong' and answers it with anything other than 'nature is a fucking bitch in Australia', please tell them to piss off in your best Hugh Jackman tones.
The lovely and admirable Ms Quentin Bryce, Governor-General of Australia has just made a gentle and compassionate plea to the nation to help where they can. In the far north of Queensland, people who have lost everything but the house in severe floods (because Australian nature s a fucking bitch with a truly twisted sense of humour) have been donating part of their emergency payments to the fire victims. The continent may be a place of horror, but the Australian people have genuine grace.
Thank you so much to everyone who has reached into their pockets to help people and animals recover from this disaster. The Australian Red Cross will take any donation from A$5 up. That's essentially a coffee.
During the writing of this post, the number at the start of this post has gone up. The police say that it will go up more.
This is not true. What is true is that the right things to do, the things that kept you alive in every other year, every other fire, are now no longer necessarily right.
Everyone who lives through an Australian summer has some experience of bushfire, even if it is only red-blazing sunsets in smoke-filled skies. The trees explode on the hot summer days, and half the flora is designed to regenerate after burning.
There are rules. You choose whether you will leave early or stay and fight. If you're leaving, you pack your papers and photos, grab the kids and pets, make sure you have water and towels or blankets in the car in case the worst happens, and you leave before or when you see the smoke. Lock the house and tell the fire brigade where it is. They'll do what they can.
Stick to the main roads, drive steadily, obey the police or the fierys, pick up pedestrians if you need to. When you get to the evacuation centre, give your names and details, call your friends. Let the officials know if you move on.
If you stay, you fill everything you can inside the house with water. You wet everything you can outside. Clear all debris from around the house (you should have done this weeks ago). Use a tractor if you have one. Fuck the garden, you can replant. Bring in the pets. Have the car nearby, have the keys in your pocket. Have your backpacks of things each of you really need ready to go. Do what you can for the horses. If the flames are small and slow, you can stay outside and keep hosing. If they're fast and large, go in. Close everything. Put wet towels around every gap, have a ladder near the roof access. Stay down, keep the kids together; the bathroom is a good place, it's cool and strong and you can sit them in the bath. If you see flames coming inside and can wet them, do so. Wait till the front passes.
This is what you do in a normal fire. This is what you have time to do in a normal fire.
When it passes, you run around the house and put out the flames that are starting inside. You climb into the roof cavity and wet down any hot spots. You go outside and use your generator to pump water from the tanks, or the pool or the dam to hose down the roof and the property. If the house is too well alight, you leave it. You grab the kids, pets and packs and you climb into the car and drive away. The car is usually all right; it's the embers blown by the wind that have set fire to the house. You can often drive out through the burnt region, there's nothing left for the fire there anymore. Your tires may be a bit fucked-up by the hot tarmac, but it doesn't matter, you'll get to the country fire authority, or the town, or the sports oval.
This is what happens normally.
You stand around with the CFA and the SES and the Parks service and every other firefighter, and you shake hands and you say thanks, or bad luck, and you pitch in if your house is standing and your neighbour's isn't, and you see about handing out sausage sandwiches and cups of bad coffee and good tea. The CWA ladies bring cakes and fruit and toys for the little ones and make sure the fierys all have a good feed and get some sleep. The McDonald's managers and the local takeaway owners bring trays of juice and water and burgers and sandwiches, the pub brings beer by the slab.
Every year, it happens. Houses burn, livestock are lost, and people turn to each other and say that it sounded like a train, that the fire moved as fast as they could run. That they lost the house but the kids are okay. It's horrible, but it's normal.
None of this is normal.
This fire moved faster than any car, twice as fast in some places. The noise was like a jet engine, they say, and the oxygen was sucked from the air leaving people sheltering inside gasping desperately as the front passed. The weather had stood above 40 for a week, the air was crisp and the vegetation bone dry. On the day the fires swept through it was 46 in Victoria.
It's never 46. Never. Not till now. The records were shattered by several degrees.
The radiant heat has been described as like Dresden. Houses were exploding into flame ahead of the firefront. While normal ember attacks give you a decent length of time for the house to stand before it is unsalvageable (the eaves and under the house start smouldering, small fires begin, but it's usually after the front has past that the house really catches light), this time large properties were gone in minutes. Normally the embers strike when the fire is up to a kilometre away, this time it was many times that.
Some people trying to escape died of dehydration before the fire reached them. Others who escaped the flames had skin crisped from their bodies as they ran well ahead or away. Some lived, and are in hospital fighting for their lives now. Cars have turned into makeshift crematoria, sometimes beside trees that are scorched from heat but not burned.
There were warnings where there could be warnings. All day the ABC and the local stations kept as far ahead of the fire as they could, but for Kinglake and some other towns, the fire moved faster than the news. The brigades were mostly fighting established fronts, trying to keep them from residential areas. The new fronts took them by surprise, many coming from nothing, possibly from arsonists.
I know that it is human to look for blame. I know that there are many who are angry and who wish to say that something or someone failed. But for the most part, no one failed. It was impossible to succeed.
There are systems. This country is used to fire and plans accordingly. The fire danger is rated from 1 to 100, so the authorities know how prepared they need to be, how many crews they need in place. On Saturday in Victoria, it was 320. More than three times worse than the experienced authorities had imagined they would ever need to prepare for. There was no way that people could deal with those flames.
And still they went out and did what they could. When I worked for the parks service in NSW I helped in two safe areas of two comparatively piddling fires. I was scared to the bones, and I am someone who keeps her head in a crisis. The sheer mental toughness of everyone who went up against those fires cannot be overstated.
So if your news service starts with the question 'what went wrong' and answers it with anything other than 'nature is a fucking bitch in Australia', please tell them to piss off in your best Hugh Jackman tones.
The lovely and admirable Ms Quentin Bryce, Governor-General of Australia has just made a gentle and compassionate plea to the nation to help where they can. In the far north of Queensland, people who have lost everything but the house in severe floods (because Australian nature s a fucking bitch with a truly twisted sense of humour) have been donating part of their emergency payments to the fire victims. The continent may be a place of horror, but the Australian people have genuine grace.
Thank you so much to everyone who has reached into their pockets to help people and animals recover from this disaster. The Australian Red Cross will take any donation from A$5 up. That's essentially a coffee.
During the writing of this post, the number at the start of this post has gone up. The police say that it will go up more.
no subject
Date: 2009-02-10 07:35 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-02-11 06:54 am (UTC)(no subject)
From:no subject
Date: 2009-02-10 09:42 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-02-11 06:55 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-02-10 09:49 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-02-12 11:13 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-02-10 09:58 pm (UTC)I can't even imagine how hellish it must be but please be safe and keep us updated?
no subject
Date: 2009-02-10 10:19 pm (UTC)The Salvation Army is also running appeals for both these fires and the fairly impressive flooding we're seeing up the other end. It's credit card only - I don't know how much good that will do you - but completely secure, and you can choose exactly where you want your money to go.
It's here. (https://secure.salvationarmy.org/)
(no subject)
From:(no subject)
From:no subject
Date: 2009-02-10 10:14 pm (UTC)*hugs*
Lucie x
no subject
Date: 2009-02-10 10:27 pm (UTC)I'm very safe. In fact New South Wales hasn't had such a 'good' fire summer in most of the time I've been in Australia. A few started up late last week, then the rains came. Lucky!
The nice thing is that most of the blaming has been from international media, and I really do understand that. It just seems impossible for such a thing to have occurred given all the preparedness and training. But, as everyone keeps saying, this is not the fire that we have seen before. The UK coverage has been largely very good in conveying that, from what I have seen and heard.
It frustrates me that there's so little any of us can do, but sending even small amounts of aid or just thoughts and love to the Victorians makes a big difference. Thanks so much for thinking of them! *hugs back*
(no subject)
From:no subject
Date: 2009-02-10 11:13 pm (UTC)Which, frankly is a bit odd, and I'm not sure how that works, but there we are.
I've slipped them a few quid. Mr Brown is also donating.
no subject
Date: 2009-02-12 11:32 am (UTC)And I am feeling a bit guilty about saying such cruel things re Mr Brown ...
(no subject)
From:(no subject)
From:(no subject)
From:(no subject)
From:(no subject)
From:(no subject)
From:(no subject)
From:no subject
Date: 2009-02-10 11:25 pm (UTC)Thank you for this, I will be linking it to anyone who starts saying "Oh they should have evacuated the minute they knew there was a fire," and generally playing the blame game. Shut up, you armchair survivalists.
If I were to blame anything, it would be climate change, and perhaps amorphously the government's paltry response to it, but that isn't going to bring anyone back from the dead or rebuild anyone's homes. All we can do is pick ourselves up, learn from this and look to the future.
no subject
Date: 2009-02-12 11:38 am (UTC)Climate change is definitely a major causal factor. I read an article today about a man who thinks he should have his fine for illegal land clearing refunded to him, because his house survived. All I could think was that his sort of attitude was the sort that lowers rain in regions and groundwater in the soil. Everyone knows that trees bring rain ... I think I have to stop reading the paper for a few days ...
no subject
Date: 2009-02-10 11:45 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-02-12 11:41 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-02-10 11:49 pm (UTC)Second since we are facing eviction my wife and I will do what we can, but know that we cry and Pray with you daily.A$5 up. That's essentially a coffee. sometimes we don't even have that but we will try. Being in Amercia and safe in Philly makes us want to do more but please tell me what can we do other than Pray and share in your grief by looking at the pictures and following the updates. We don't have TV so we don't get any news.
Also I was hoping you might clear something up for me. I've heard that the main fire might have been delibertly set. Is there any truth in that?
Stay safe and may I friend you to keep abreast of things.
Love and Prayers
Deborah
no subject
Date: 2009-02-12 11:56 am (UTC)I hope that things work out with you, I know that your country is facing a crisis that is far broader in scope than this one, if not as immediately horrifying. We are all thinking of you, too
It seems that at least one of the fatal fires was started by arson, and another is thought very suspicious. The police are being very cautious in their pronouncements, but it does not look as though the news will be good. And yes, of course you can friend me, but I should warn you that it's usually Harry Potter slash, bad language, ranting and book reviews here.
XXX BB
(no subject)
From:no subject
Date: 2009-02-11 12:54 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-02-12 11:58 am (UTC)I have this dream that even if everyone on my flist can't afford to donate a few dollars, they can all turn to anyone who says 'Oh, what idiots' and say 'Actually ...'
But you can see why I live in the city and don't bushwalk in summer. It's just grim.
no subject
Date: 2009-02-11 01:04 am (UTC)This. A thousand times this. Thank you.
A friend who works at the Victorian Coroner's Court told me they've been told to expect at least 300 deaths. It's grim, and horrible, but it was no-one's fault for following established procedures.
(here via
no subject
Date: 2009-02-12 12:00 pm (UTC)Every time Christine Nixon warns that there will be more bodies, it seems all the more real and more awful.
no subject
Date: 2009-02-11 02:27 am (UTC)One of the things which has struck me most, actually, has been the lack of frantic blame, the lack of hysterical grief. The country Australian reputation for laid backness in action - you hear interviews on the radio, the soundbites chosen for maximum effect, and these people who have lost everything, who spent hours being terrified, who saw this incredible disaster - they sound a bit shaken, maybe. They say they'd never seen anything like the fire and then say that the emergency services have been really great, they're impressed with how well set up the relief centres are. They agree with the interviewer, it's been pretty bad, but they'll get by, right?
It's kind of amazing.
no subject
Date: 2009-02-11 09:44 am (UTC)(no subject)
From:(no subject)
From:no subject
Date: 2009-02-11 03:16 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-02-12 12:10 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-02-11 03:56 am (UTC)Very well said and everything is true.
I've received so many emails asking what went wrong and why wasn't everyone prepared. I live in Sydney, on a mountain, surrounded by vegetation and every year we do the same thing, clear the gutters, mow the lawns, dispose of anything that could possibly start a fire.
After the bushfires here a couple of Christmases ago, we started to prepare packs just in case no matter the temperature because nature is a bitch. The weather is unpredictable and you never have enough time. There is no such thing as enough time.
I've pointed all of this out to people and I've yelled at the stupid experts on CNN who want to place blame on the wrong people. It was the weather (and arsonists? I'm not too sure of the facts right there)and we can only do what we can do. The right thing isn't always enough.
I'm about to make a similar post on my lj about donating. Would it be ok if I linked to this post? You said everything I want to say only better.
no subject
Date: 2009-02-11 06:38 am (UTC)You certainly can. If I just manage to help a few people understand why there were no easy solutions, I'll be happy. If the Red Cross can earn a little, I'll be thrilled.
I think that it's just too hard to understand if you've never been here or never lived in the bush. When I first moved to Sydney I lived on the upper North Shore and had just moved out when the 93-94 fires hit my old suburb. I did some piddling work helping clean up spot fires during those days in areas that had many escape roads.
Since then I have lived in Newtown or Erskineville. I will NEVER live in or near the bush here unless I have enough money for a moat, and all-brass sprinklers, and a pet CFA, it's just too unpredictable. And I formed those fears based on a fire which, as my fire-fighting friend has said, was a campfire compared to this one. I am just in awe of the Victorian CFA and everyone else who fought over the last week.
As to arsonists, there have definitely been some active in both Victoria and NSW, though the ones that have been seen or caught have been responsible for small non-lethal fires as far as I know. As for whether they were responsible for the major fronts that have hit Marysville, Kinglake and so on, I know they are being cautious about attributing causes at the moment, so it could be months before we know, if ever.
Anyway ... *Waves again* Keep your gutters clear! I hope the wet continues up here!
(no subject)
From:(no subject)
From:no subject
Date: 2009-02-11 04:40 am (UTC)The fact the fire was moving faster than cars sends chills through me. I'm plannong on donating some money because it's the least I can do. I don't know anyone directly affected by the fires (Although some of my perthite friends moved to Victoria) but they all know someone who has been.
Nothing could have prepared anyone for a firestorm moving over 200km an hour and over 4 storeys high in some places. Nobody :(
no subject
Date: 2009-02-12 12:15 pm (UTC)And you are exactly right, there was nothing that could have prepared them.
(no subject)
From:no subject
Date: 2009-02-11 07:19 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-02-12 12:22 pm (UTC)Thank you so much for your support on your lj! I am way behind, but it is wonderful that you could help to spread the news and ways people could help.
no subject
Date: 2009-02-11 07:34 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-02-12 12:24 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-02-11 09:02 am (UTC)I had already planned on donating money, and I were living there, I'd probably provide more. Not because it's horrific (though it is) or it's a nice gesture (though it is). I'd do it because it's right. You help out. You take care. You remember people matter. I'll donate more in a couple weeks because I have a feeling what's being donated now will be used up in a week, if not less. So I'll wait and give more then.
It's so wrong and terrible and wrong. There's not words. I'm from the southeast US where brushfires are more limited to Florida. But I know about nature's bitchy attitudes and capricious nature. We had a tornado in the beginning of March that ripped through Atlanta. We have our hurricanes and their destructive selves. As much as it hurts as humans, answers don't always appear. Sometimes a bad thing is just a bad thing. The only blame that can be attributed are the arsonists and I have faith your system will convict them.
When my godmother dies, which could be a decade or more, I'm planning on moving to Australia. Not that I've been, but it's one of the few places I can pin on a map and say "that's it." Others are far more local, but there's also Rome. There's something about your country, though. It calls. How can I hope help a land calling?
no subject
Date: 2009-02-12 01:01 pm (UTC)My mother is Australian, but I grew up in England and came out to visit. I had never seen anywhere with such space and skies, and I fell in love, and stayed. On its best days, it is a country of surpassing loveliness. Sadly, it has bad days that are just as extreme. I am sure that it will capture your heart if you have the chance to move here. (Though I would say that, as I love Florence and Siena above Rome ;-)
Two of the arsonists are now in custody, there are moves against several others. Things will Be Sorted.
(no subject)
From:no subject
Date: 2009-02-11 09:37 am (UTC)I grew up in the shadow of the Blue Mountains in NSW. My grandparents and aunt and uncle were evacuated in '94. My mother told stories of the fires in the '60s and '70s, the mountains alight as far as the eye could see, the sky black and raining burnt leaves on suburban Penrith houses, miles away.
No one who knows Australia and knows fires could blame anyone for this. This is one of those horrific fires that happens once every ten years or so that can't be controlled. If we're lucky, they just burn through miles of National Park, far away from settlement. If we're not, then we pay the price.
no subject
Date: 2009-02-11 12:41 pm (UTC)On Monday, I sat there while NSW firefighters did all the stupid blaming referenced here in this post, and I did not know enough about normal fires or about THESE fires to contradict the assessment that 107 people had died of 'stupidity'.
no subject
Date: 2009-02-11 12:08 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-02-11 12:47 pm (UTC)As to the arsonists, it does now look as though at least one of the fatal fires was set on purpose. I don't like to think what will happen to the culprit/s if they are caught, though I am afraid they'll deserve it.
no subject
Date: 2009-02-11 12:39 pm (UTC)Thank you.
My boss is a firefighter, and like many firefighters, she thinks she knows everything about fire, and that no one should die in a fire unless they're stupid. Apparently 200 or so people died of 'panic'. If I weren't new to the job, I'd slam her a link to this...
no subject
Date: 2009-02-11 12:45 pm (UTC)You can't be prone to panic if you live in the bush. Everything is poised to kill you from the snakes to the spiders to the fire to the floods to some of the crankier sheep. You'd never leave the house. Has she been reading any of the coverage in the Herald? The firefighters' stories have me in awe that they could save anyone at all.
(no subject)
From:(no subject)
From:no subject
Date: 2009-02-11 01:21 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-02-11 01:25 pm (UTC)Got linked here by iamshadow
Date: 2009-02-11 02:29 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-02-11 03:37 pm (UTC)I am so sorry for the suffering of everyone.
Best of luck and speed in the recovery/rebuilding.
no subject
Date: 2009-02-12 01:02 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-02-11 05:52 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-02-12 01:03 pm (UTC)